Books Like Who Would Win - 15 Similar Series (2026)
Your kids devoured every Who Would Win book and want more? You're not alone. Jerry Pallotta's series has created millions of animal-battle-obsessed readers.
Here are the best alternatives — plus one solution that gives them infinite matchups.
The Best Who Would Win Alternatives
1. Animal Battles (Bellwether Media)
Ages: 6-9 Reading Level: Grades 2-3Books in Series: 20+
The most direct competitor to Who Would Win. Same format — two animals, stats comparison, battle verdict.
Matchups include:
- Anaconda vs. Jaguar
- Lion vs. Cape Buffalo
- Polar Bear vs. Wolverine
- Crocodile vs. Hippo
Why kids love it: Feels exactly like Who Would Win with different matchups.
Why it's different: More photographs, less illustration. Slightly shorter books.
2. National Geographic Kids Readers
Ages: 5-9 Reading Level: Levels 1-3Books in Series: 100+
Not battle-focused, but packed with amazing animal facts, stunning photography, and the engaging style kids love.
Best for Who Would Win fans:
- Deadliest Animals
- Predator Face-Off
- Ocean Animals Collection
- Sharks!
Why kids love it: Real photos, incredible facts, similar "wow factor."
Why it's different: Educational focus, not battle format.
3. Who Would Win? (Scholastic) — The Rumble Books
Ages: 6-10Reading Level: Grades 2-4
If your kids only read the one-on-one battles, they might have missed the RUMBLE books — tournament-style battles with 16+ animals competing.
Rumble titles:
- Ultimate Bug Rumble
- Ultimate Shark Rumble
- Ultimate Jungle Rumble
- Ultimate Ocean Rumble
- Extreme Animal Rumble (80 animals!)
Why they're great: More animals, bracket-style tournaments, longer reads.
4. Predator vs. Prey Series (Raintree)
Ages: 7-10Reading Level: Grades 3-4
Focuses on real predator-prey relationships in nature. More educational, less hypothetical battles.
Titles include:
- Shark vs. Seal
- Lion vs. Zebra
- Wolf vs. Moose
- Eagle vs. Snake
Why kids love it: Real hunting scenarios, dramatic action.
Why it's different: Based on actual predator-prey dynamics, not fantasy matchups.
5. Xtreme Animals Series (Scholastic)
Ages: 6-9Reading Level: Grades 2-3
Highlights the most extreme animals in different categories — biggest, fastest, deadliest, weirdest.
Why kids love it: Mind-blowing animal facts and records.
Great for: Kids who love the stats aspect of Who Would Win.
6. Animal Face-Off (Discovery Channel Books)
Ages: 8-12Reading Level: Grades 4-6
Based on the Discovery Channel show. More detailed, older-reader version of animal battles.
Matchups include:
- Elephant vs. Rhino
- Hippo vs. Bull Shark
- Lion vs. Crocodile
- Sperm Whale vs. Giant Squid
Why kids love it: TV show connection, more detailed analysis.
Why it's different: Aimed at older readers, more scientific depth.
7. Creature Files Series
Ages: 7-10Reading Level: Grades 3-4
Deep dives into single animals with fold-out pages, flaps, and interactive elements.
Why kids love it: Hands-on elements, detailed information.
Best for: Kids who want to become experts on their favorite animals.
8. Weird But True! (National Geographic Kids)
Ages: 6-10 Reading Level: Grades 2-4Books in Series: 12+
Not animal-specific, but packed with mind-blowing facts that Who Would Win fans devour.
Why kids love it: Quick facts, no long reading required, endless "did you know?" moments.
9. Dinosaur Battles (Various Publishers)
If your kids love the dinosaur Who Would Win books, there's a whole genre of dino battle content:
Options:
- Jurassic Smackdown (National Geographic)
- Dinosaur Combat (Capstone)
- Dino Wars (DK)
Why kids love it: Dinosaurs + battles = ultimate combo.
10. Steve Jenkins Books
Ages: 5-9Author/Illustrator: Steve Jenkins
Beautiful cut-paper illustrations with amazing animal comparisons. Not battle format, but similar "compare and contrast" appeal.
Best titles:
- Biggest, Strongest, Fastest
- What Do You Do With a Tail Like This?
- Actual Size
Why kids love it: Stunning visuals, surprising comparisons.
Beyond Books: Other Who Would Win Content
YouTube Channels
- Animal Face-Off — Fan-made battle videos
- Casual Geographic — Educational animal content with humor
- PBS Eons — For older kids interested in prehistoric animals
Video Games
- Zoo Tycoon — Build habitats, learn about animals
- Jurassic World Evolution — Dinosaur management (older kids)
Podcasts
- Wow in the World (NPR) — Science for kids
- But Why: A Podcast for Curious Kids — Often features animal questions
The Problem with Alternatives
Here's the thing: even with all these great options, they have the same limitation as Who Would Win itself.
There are only so many books.
Your kid wants to know:
- "Who would win, Gorilla vs. Grizzly Bear?"
- "What about Hippo vs. Crocodile?"
- "Could a Honey Badger beat a Wolverine?"
And if Jerry Pallotta hasn't written that matchup... they're stuck.
The Unlimited Solution: Custom Battle Books
What if your kids could create their own Who Would Win matchups?
We built exactly that.
How it works:
1. Pick any two animals
2. We generate a complete battle book with real facts
3. Read the comparison, stats, and battle
4. Find out who wins based on science
Matchups you can't find anywhere else:
- Gorilla vs. Grizzly Bear
- Great White Shark vs. Saltwater Crocodile
- Wolverine vs. Honey Badger
- Elephant vs. Hippo
- ANY combination your kids can imagine
Why it works:
- Same educational format as Who Would Win
- Real animal facts and statistics
- Illustrated battle scenes
- Instant generation — no waiting for Jerry to write it
Frequently Asked Questions
What books are similar to Who Would Win?
The most similar series is Animal Battles by Bellwether Media, which uses the same format of comparing two animals and declaring a winner. National Geographic Kids Readers and the Predator vs. Prey series are also great alternatives.
What age is Who Would Win for?
Who Would Win books are designed for ages 6-10 (grades 1-4). The Lexile levels range from 560-850, making them perfect for independent reading in grades 2-3.
Are there more Who Would Win books coming out?
Yes! Jerry Pallotta releases several new titles each year. Recent additions include Panther vs. Leopard and Monstrous Mammals. Check Scholastic or the author's website for new releases.
What if my kids want a matchup that doesn't exist?
That's why we created custom battle books! Pick any two animals and generate a complete Who Would Win-style book instantly. Try it here →
Are Who Would Win books educational?
Yes! Each book contains real scientific facts about animal size, speed, strength, diet, habitat, and special abilities. They're popular in classrooms for teaching nonfiction reading and animal science.
Keep the Battle Going
Your kids' love of animal battles is actually a love of learning — about nature, science, and how the world works.
Whether they read every Who Would Win book, explore the alternatives above, or create their own custom matchups, you're feeding a healthy curiosity about the natural world.
Browse Our Complete Who Would Win Book Guide →
Create Your Own Custom Matchup →
Not affiliated with Jerry Pallotta, Scholastic, or any publishers mentioned. We're just fans who wanted more animal battles!
CREATE YOUR OWN BATTLE BOOK
See this matchup fully illustrated with AI-generated artwork. Free for popular battles.
🦁 Generate Book Now
